1st Congressional: Shakedown, Breakdown, Takedown (Part 1)

Much appreciate the introduction-

Well, I was going to be Capt. Obvious, but unfortunately some smart, good looking, sarcastic, individual beat me to it. Thus, I figured I’d give myself a promotion and change my last name- thus, Major T. J. ‘King’ Kong, shortened to Major Kong. Made famous by the 1964 movie classic,  Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying, and Love the Bomb.

I wanted to get things off on the right foot with all the great folks here at VV, so I figured I’d couple my first blog with a little 80’s music.  Who better, than Bob Seger and his 1987 single “Shakedown”?  (Friday Night Video Fights, anyone?) As Seger so masterfully said twenty years ago, ‘breakdown, shakedown, takedown- everyone wants into the crowded light’.

Right now in VA, that lyric can be exemplified by the laundry list of ‘potential’ candidates jockeying behind the scenes for a position, to what appears to be a lightning quick Special Election. To name a few: Delegates Gear, Frederick, Lingamfelter, Hamilton and Whitman, along with former Delegate Melanie Rapp; State Senator Ryan McDougle, Lt. Gov. Bill Bollling; Former 1st Congressional Chairman Russ Moulton and current Chairman James Bowden; Stafford County Commissioner of the Revenue Scott Mayausky; Former 1st Congressional District Candidate, and current Virginia Club for Growth President, Paul Jost; VV’s own Jim Riley, an attorney and GOP activist/1st Congressional Committee member; Kevin O’Neil, a lobbyist; and finally (and most likely) Chuck Davis, widower of the late Congresswoman Davis.

As stated, it initially appears to look like events are going to begin to unfold fairly fast. Governor Kaine has stated that he would like to see a Special Election before, ’the end of the year’.  Assuming the Special Election won’t coincide with the upcoming Nov. 6th elections, and by statute thus, not taking place until 30 days after the November elections, the calendar could look something like this: (working backwards):

  • Special Election Tuesday December 18th. Now I’m not sure if the Special Election has to take place on a Tuesday, but if it does, then the latest it could take place, is on December 18th, as Christmas falls on Tuesday the 25th.
  • Nomination Contest (likely Convention) Saturday December 1st. Why convention? There will not be a statewide primary, for a plethora or reasons. Thus nominations will either be determined by party canvass or by convention. The first congressional (for both R’s and D’s) may be the weakest congressional district in the state from an organizational standpoint. There is no district ’seat’, because there isn’t an area of dense population. Thus the local committees and their respective memberships are small, some so small they meet only quarterly. A full-blown party canvass requires volunteers, and lots of them. Volunteers that neither party could produce, unless a large influx of out-of-the-district vols come to their aid- which isn’t likely, not that time of year.  Therefore a convention seems, by far, the easiest route- for both parties. (Bonus: The bonus for Gov. Tim Kaine is that by setting the convention for this weekend, he’ll place a huge damper on the State GOP’s Annual Huffman Advance. Attendance would surely be down, and not by simply 1/11. Party leaders, state elected officials, election attorneys and the rest of the circus would all be unable to attend their yearly merrymaking.

With the candidates and calendar now, at least potentially, set- I’ll explore in Part 2 (the ‘breakdown’) all the possible scenarios, maneuvering, and deal making, including what seems to be the two most likely directions the GOP nomination might swing. While someone will surely be positioned for victory, others may be in the midst of being propped up for future (08’) failure.

I’ll also leave open the possibility of tapping out a ‘Part 3′, (the ‘takedown’) that will identify the potential Democratic candidates in this race. A much smaller list of names has been floating around the District and DC, and although the 1st Congressional is a solid GOP District- somewhere around 55/45, there could be a real opportunity there for a well-qualified, connected, democratic candidate to pick that seat off. I know many of you, maybe all of you, would disagree, but I think the argument can be made given; the Governor’s authority to set the calendar, the short cycle, and the dismal turnout that is to be expected.  There is, at least, a remote possibility. I may even convince you that the possibility of that happening, is actually pretty strong.   

26 Responses to “1st Congressional: Shakedown, Breakdown, Takedown (Part 1)”

  1. These are all good people. As to the list though, I can’t see those who are running for a Nov 6th election or those currently in office running for the seat though in good faith of their committments. Wouldn’t it be awkward to say the least for them to switch in mid-stream or with a brand spankin’ new win under their belt?

    While any of them could perform the duties technically, most are not experienced enough in this level of play to win an 08 competitive election with a strong Dem opponent.

    Jo Ann won with little experience under her belt, but the Dems won’t let that happen again, especially in this feeding frenzy at the national level. We need someone with not only the ability, but the credentials too– who isn’t pre-committed to a current post– the main problem with being labeled as abandonment and selfish pursuit of power in a vacuum.

    Furthermore, we need these good folks at these state-level posts to hold down the fort! If they all quit to run- who will fill all those seats??

    Ambition is great, but we only win as a team if we cover all our levels and bases with good people. Lest we have 15 candidates who drop out of their current jobs they were elected to do and leave 15 vacancies to pursue one seat. Only one can win this seat, but we ALL lose if a dozen pursue it.

  2. I am hearing Anne Petera and Bill Bolling also being mentioned as candidates for the GOP nomination.

  3. Sorry, but there’s a big flaw in your timeline: the nominatees must be selected at least 30 days before the special election, unless the writ of special election is issued less than 35 days before the special election. So, to work for you, Governor Kaine would have to issue the writ after Thanksgiving for a December 18 special election, in order to allow a December 1 nomination deadline.

    (Moreover, a December 18 special puts canvassing and certification into the holidays, jeopardizing the seating of the new representative when the House convenes in January.)

    The more likely timeline is a December 11 special, a November 11 nomination deadline, and a writ sometime between now and Halloween.

  4. And by nominatees, I mean nominees.

  5. I think Mr. Davis probably would be the favorite should he choose to run but I do think the right person can indeed beat him.

    First I think the nominee will probably be a sitting member of the Virginia General Assembly. These folks have the most contacts with operatives and lobbyist on a daily basis. I think Lt. Gov will think twice and keep his seat because he would risk complete alienation if he quits less than 1/2 way through his term. 1st district convention voters do not want anonymous GOP higher ups picking the nominee.
    Second, I think it will be someone who is very strong on the social issues. This is a military district so family values are of extreme importance and Congresswoman Davis really was a model of this.
    Third, knowledge of the military. While not a necessity. Somone who has served will have an advantage just becaues they will be familiar with the issues facing the 1st.

    All that being said, if Mr. Davis does not run. I think Witman because of his location and likeability, Lingamfelter because of his military experience (I think he was a career military guy), and Russ Moulton because of all his contacts in the district would be the favorites in a late December, short notice matchup. Plus all of the above are staunch social conservatives. One might throw Gear in there but I just don’t see it.

    In the end, we really don’t even know who is really interested in running or who is just jockying for something else down the road.

  6. I think so long as a military, conservative, experienced, person steps up for the interim position that we’ll be fine. But it should be someone who can hold the seat come next November in a tough race. If the Dems smell weakness, they’ll pour a million bucks into the race. If the person (like Jo Ann was) seems almost unbeatable, they’ll put their efforts elsewhere. I don’t see how it could be a sitting member (or recently elected) for the reasons stated above no matter how right they’d be for the job itself. Russ Moulton certainly fits the mold (except for lack of military experience- a big detractor in the 1st), but isn’t known by the people nearly as much as the political arena. He would make a great campaign manager, but perhaps not a strong candidate. I don’t think he/his candidates have won a race though have they?

    Wittman and Lingamfelter have the office experience and electability, but lack the ‘availability’ if they’re sitting in office, and would create two open seats we’d have to scramble to fill. Are they known outside their home district though by Hard-R’s? The 1st is a BIG district to cover (I don’t know- that’s not rhetorical)

  7. The Dems may pour a good deal of money into the special election, but if they don’t win, they are not going to throw good money after bad in 08–it simply makes no sense.

    In the worst year a Republican is likely ever to have–06–Allen still beat Webb by nearly 30,000 votes. On top of that, as the DNC’s own internal polling is telling them, if, as expected, Hillary is at the top of the ticket, they can kiss good bye at least 10-15 vulnerable seats in the South and any chance of winning any red-leaning seats in Dixie.

    Mark my words, as Hillary solidifies her control of the Dem nomination, you will see more and more stories about Dems laying heavy money on some Midwestern seats. Why? Because the Dems will essentially have to write off 10 seats in the South at a bare minimum, and will have to find a way to make up for it. Apparently, there voting data suggests that Hillary isn’t as despised by independents in the Midwest and that would be the proper place to pour out their sizable war chest.

  8. Forgive my ignorance on the subject, but does Mr. Davis have political experience too? Is he running for sure? I wouldn’t have thought of his candidacy before now…

  9. First, a special election would have to be held December 11th, if it is to be held this year, because state law dictates that it must be held at least 30 days after the November 6th election and 60 days before any other election; Virginia’s presidential primary is February 12th.

    Second, there’s no need for a sitting member of the General Assembly to resign to run for office. The GA isn’t back in session until January.

  10. how about Speaker Howell?

  11. Will the Speaker run for the seat? It seems to me that he can do so much more for Virginia where he is (not the level, but the senior rank) and help get other Republicans elected too across the state.

    He’ll have to explain to his voters that he’s in the race now for, that he appreciates their vote over two other canididates, but “gotta run for congress now, buh bye.” I just don’t kow how one can do that successfully.

    He hasn’t been totally consistent with his message as of late especially with championing the absusive driver’s fees, and teaming up with Chichester on several occasions, so that could hurt, but he’s a good man overall and is well known and strong on military affairs….

    well, that’s one (if he’ll run)- any others?

  12. Another name poped up David Caparara. It looks like a slim chance there. Didn’t do to good against Herbert Bateman.
    THE VIRGINIAN-PILOT
    Copyright (c) 1996, Landmark Communications, Inc.

    DATE: Wednesday, June 12, 1996 TAG: 9606120487
    SECTION: FRONT PAGE: A13 EDITION: FINAL
    SOURCE: ASSOCIATED PRESS
    DATELINE: RICHMOND LENGTH: 64 lines

    ——————————————————————————–

    BATEMAN HAS NO TROUBLE DEFEATING LITTLE-KNOWN GOP FOE IN 1ST DISTRICT THE SEVEN-TERM CONGRESSMAN GARNERS 80 PERCENT OF PRIMARY BALLOTS.
    Seven-term U.S. Rep. Herbert H. Bateman easily beat back a challenge from social conservative David L. Caprara on Tuesday to win the Republican primary in Virginia’s 1st District.

    With all precincts reporting, unofficial totals showed Bateman with 49,511 votes, or 80 percent, and Caprara with 12,648 votes, or 20 percent. The challenger lost in his home base in the Fredericksburg area.

  13. THERE’S JUST ONE NAME FOR WHO CAN LEAD THE FIRST CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT TO REPUBLICAN VICTORY, AND WHO WILL LEAD THE US HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES TO A REPUBLICAN REVOLUTION, AND THAT NAME IS THIS:

    COL. RICHARD H. BLACK

    Bye for now,
    Laura

  14. Col. Black would be an *EXCELLENT* candidate– good call Laura!

    Can anyone match his record? Certainly no Democrat!!!! Strong conservative, amazing military record, tremendous VA Delegate record, very likeable among Republicans to the core… the more I think about it- I’m upgrading excellent to *FANTASTIC*!

    PS ease up on the all caps L ;-)

  15. Hahaha,

    Dick Black would get killed by any of the above mentioned candidates just because his candidacy would be the ultimate carpet bagging job. Loudoun is not even close to the first.

    If Black were to get the nomination the this seat would be a solid pickup for the dems. There are plenty of delegates who are socially conservative but not crazy about it that actually represent the 1st district in their house seats who would make fine candidates. (Wittman, Lingamfelter, and Jear) who might actually be considering running. If Blacks arguement is he is the only one with military experience, Lingamfelter has as much or more as Black and is a mainstream social conservative. We don’t need Loudoun GOP moving into the 1st to run.He has certainly caused enough problems in his own county. This has to be a joke ! Black could run but no one in the first would take him seriously at all.

  16. Sounds like you may have something. Where can I see this record?

  17. I would like to see Dick Blacks record as I said. He lives in Virginia doesn’t he?

  18. You don’t have to live in the 1st district to represent it. Twocents sounds like he has a personal issue more so than a political one. If the Viet Cong couldn’t kill Black, I doubt a Democrat could. Lingamfelter doesn’t like in the first either, so that blows your point. You bring up “joke” and “crazy” a little too easily. Black has a rock solid conservative record of success and is well liked and known throughout the 1st. He’ll do just fine.

  19. Laura: Black should run, because he did so well 2005.

    Big Shoes: A dem could still pick up this seat in a Special. We’re not talking a full-scale general election, so toss that ‘30,000 vote margin’ right out the window. In a Special Election, turnout would be ridiculously low, there wouldn’t be 30,000 toal votes cast.

    Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying a dem Would win, but that one Could win, given the low turnout. If they would choose the right candidate, which I think they may indeed have one (whether he’s willing to run or not is still in the air), they could win this Special. I don’t care who the GOP runs.

    I’ll explore it more in part 3. Will place part 2 up tommorrow- my apologies for the delay.

  20. Black a “record of success.” You gotta be kidding me? Just take a look at the current state of the Loudoun GOP and his electoral success in 2005 and tell me it again. Black is the only Republican who could have lost that HOD seat. Somone who lives in Loudoun and has never represented any part of the 1st district has absolutely no chance whatsoever. If he wants a seat so bad and he is “pure” as a conservative why does he not challenge Frank Wolf to a primary? I think we all know the answer.

  21. COL RICHARD H BLACK has extremely strong ties in the First Congressional.

    He held his House of Delegates seat for almost a decade, while about five times as many Dems as R’s were flooding into that Dirstrict. He built up the party. I was there and saw it. Over that time, he championed some of the best legislation conservatives have ever seen. He never voted for a tax increase. He is the father of Virginia’s parental consent law that literally saves lives. He has our respect and may he lead Virginia — and our Nation — in the First.

    COL. RICHARD H. BLACK’s record is below. (I found it on the web.)

    100% Rating: National Assn. of Independent Business

    100% Rating: Family Foundation

    100% Rating: Fairfax County Taxpayers Association

    A+ Rating: National Rifle Association

    National Right to Work: America’s Top Legislator for 2003

    Family Foundation: Northern Virginia Legislator of the Year, 2003

    Christian Coalition: Chairman, Northern Virginia 1993-95

    Brent Society: Distinguished Legislator of 2006–“for constant and courageous defense of innocent human life, the sanctity of marriage, and the traditional family.”

    Church of the Valley: American Eagle Award for 2007–”for bold defense of family values.”

    Tax Payers Pledge: Signed it and kept it. I never voted any tax in eight years.

    – Laura

  22. ” He built up the party” Thats a bunch of baloney. Just look at his local party now!!!! Almost any other Republican would have kept this seat in GOP hands.
    He has absolutely no chance just because he wold be the biggest carpetbagger this state ever saw.
    If he runs he will get well under 10%.

    May I ask what ties he has in the first?

  23. mytwocents why would you call a fellow Virginian a carpetbagger? His votes affect the whole state and the Country. Don’t you realize that?
    Seems like quite a record.

  24. Black has helped people in the 1st for a decade or more. I listened to him on the radio in Hampton about a year ago debating 2 Dems for more than an hour and they both conceeded he had great points in the end. I think 2cents is a Dem trying to pull us apart.

    Black paved the way for parental consent abortion laws when no one else would approach the hot subject. He’s WRITTEN more legislation than most any seated delegate today with more seniority.

    We have about 10-15 people interested in this seat, but I would stand Blacks record of REAL achievement against any of their promises or intentions. If someone else can match or beat his record, I’d vote for them and tell Black to take a back seat, but I haven’t seen one!

    He brought several people into politics including Mark Cole and a few more names I can’t remember that far back who are in the 1st District still today, so he’ll have a lot of local support. Black has shown up and worked hard on the stump for dozens of Republicans STATE WIDE.

    Twocents accusations are unfounded and ignorant. Black would be an excellent choice.

  25. Consider Bowden. He will make a great congressman.

  26. Go Dick Black!

Leave a Reply